Criminal Defense Attorney Kevin Kennedy prosecuted assault fear of bodily injury cases as a prosecutor in the Davidson County District Attorney’s Office. He now uses that perspective to defend clients accused of assault fear of bodily injury. Kevin holds his law degree from Vanderbilt Law School and is an active member of the Tennessee Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers.
Client Reviews
What Clients Say
“10/10 was a great help in working my case and helped to an extraordinary degree communicating everything that was going on and that would transpire. I completely would recommend Kevin Kennedy to anyone that needs legal help!!!!”CameronOur Results
Criminal defense attorney Kevin Kennedy prosecuted assault cases involving alleged threats and fear of bodily injury as a prosecutor in the Davidson County District Attorney’s Office. He now uses that experience to defend clients accused of assault by causing fear of imminent bodily injury. Kevin holds his law degree from Vanderbilt Law School and is an active member of the Tennessee Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers.
This page covers the fear-based assault theory specifically. For the broader picture, see our Nashville assault defense overview and the simple assault page. When the allegation involves an actual injury rather than fear of one, see the assault bodily injury page.
What Is Assault by Fear of Bodily Injury in Tennessee?
Tennessee Code Annotated § 39-13-101(a)(2) defines one form of assault as intentionally or knowingly causing another person to reasonably fear imminent bodily injury. Each word in that definition does work. The conduct must be intentional or knowing; the fear must be reasonable; and the feared injury must be imminent—immediate, not speculative.
Physical contact is not required. That is what distinguishes this theory from the bodily-injury theory under subsection (a)(1) and the offensive-contact theory under subsection (a)(3). A charge can rest entirely on what was said, how the accused moved, and what the alleged victim perceived.
Can You Be Charged With Assault Without Touching Someone?
Yes. Tennessee assault charges can arise without any physical contact at all. Allegations commonly involve threatening gestures, aggressive movements, raising a fist, lunging toward someone, reaching toward a pocket or waistband, or cornering someone during a confrontation.
The absence of contact does not make the charge automatic, however. The State still has to prove that the conduct actually caused the other person to fear imminent bodily injury, that the fear was reasonable, and that the accused acted intentionally or knowingly. A startled reaction to an innocent movement is not the same as statutory assault.
What Does Reasonable Fear of Imminent Bodily Injury Mean?
Reasonableness is an objective check on a subjective claim. The question is not only what the alleged victim felt, but whether a reasonable person in those circumstances would have feared imminent bodily injury. Distance between the parties, the words used, gestures, size and physical ability, access to a weapon, barriers, and the alleged victim’s immediate behavior all bear on reasonableness.
Imminence is equally important. The statute concerns injury that appears immediate. A threat of harm tomorrow, next week, or “if I see you again” is a threat of future harm, not fear of imminent bodily injury. That distinction between an immediate threat and a threatened future harm can be the center of the defense.
Do Words Alone Constitute Assault in Tennessee?
Words matter, but they are rarely the whole analysis. Tennessee courts look at statements together with the accompanying conduct: tone, movement, proximity, and what happened immediately before and after. A heated insult exchanged at a distance presents a different picture than a threat delivered while advancing on someone with a raised hand.
The defense should avoid categorical assumptions in either direction. Neither “words can never be assault” nor “any threat is assault” accurately states the law. The facts of the encounter, preserved in video, audio, and witness accounts, are what the case will turn on.
How Do Prosecutors Prove Fear of Bodily Injury?
- Witness testimony about what was said and done.
- Alleged victim statements to officers and in court.
- 911 recordings capturing tone, background sounds, and contemporaneous accounts.
- Surveillance video from businesses, homes, and doorbell cameras.
- Police body camera footage of the scene and the parties.
- Statements made during the encounter, including texts or messages around it.
- The circumstances surrounding the alleged threat—distance, gestures, and any objects involved.
Each of these sources can also help the defense. A 911 call may show calm rather than fear. Body-camera footage may capture a first account that differs from later testimony. The full recording and timeline matter more than any single selected moment.
Penalties for Assault by Fear of Bodily Injury
Assault under § 39-13-101(a)(2) is a Class A misdemeanor in Tennessee. A Class A misdemeanor carries a maximum sentence of up to 11 months and 29 days in jail, with fines and probation conditions possible depending on the case. The actual outcome depends on the facts, the defendant’s record, and how the case is resolved.
Even a misdemeanor conviction can carry collateral consequences for employment, professional licensing, and—when the relationship qualifies as domestic—firearm rights. Those consequences should be part of any decision about how to resolve the charge.
Defenses to Assault by Fear of Bodily Injury
Lack of Reasonable Fear
If the alleged victim’s reaction was not reasonable under the circumstances—or if the evidence shows no genuine fear at all—the State’s theory weakens. Behavior immediately after the encounter, such as staying at the scene, continuing an argument, or delaying any report, can be relevant.
Lack of Imminence
A threat of future harm does not satisfy the statute. When the alleged statement or gesture concerned something that might happen later, the imminence element is open to challenge.
Lack of the Required Mental State
The prosecution must prove intentional or knowing conduct. An accidental movement, a misunderstood gesture, or conduct the accused did not realize would cause fear may not satisfy the charged mental state.
Self-Defense and Defense of Others
Tennessee’s justification statutes, §§ 39-11-611 and 39-11-612, can apply to fear-based allegations. A person who responds to a perceived threat may have a lawful justification, depending on the immediacy of the threat and the reasonableness of the response.
Conflicting Witness Statements and Video
Witnesses often describe the same encounter differently. Surveillance, doorbell, and cellphone video can contradict the allegation entirely. Counsel should gather recordings quickly, before they are overwritten, and compare every statement against them.
Can Assault by Fear of Bodily Injury Be Dismissed?
Dismissal is possible in the right case. Evidentiary weaknesses—no corroboration, unreasonable or absent fear, no imminence, or video that contradicts the accusation—can lead prosecutors to reduce or dismiss a charge, and can support a defense verdict at trial. Diversion or other resolutions may also be available depending on the defendant’s history. Every case turns on its own evidence, and no outcome can be guaranteed.
Why Hire a Former Nashville Prosecutor?
Kevin Kennedy handled assault cases from the prosecution side in the Davidson County District Attorney’s Office before founding his defense practice. He knows how prosecutors evaluate fear-based allegations, what evidence they consider essential, and where these cases tend to be weakest. That perspective shapes the defense strategy from the first consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions About Fear-Based Assault
Can you be charged with assault if you never touched anyone?
Yes. Tennessee Code Annotated § 39-13-101(a)(2) allows an assault charge based on intentionally or knowingly causing another person to reasonably fear imminent bodily injury. Physical contact is not an element of that theory, but the State must still prove reasonable fear, imminence, and the required mental state beyond a reasonable doubt.
Is fear-based assault a felony in Tennessee?
Ordinarily no. Assault under § 39-13-101(a)(2) is a Class A misdemeanor. It can become a felony aggravated assault when additional statutory facts are proven, such as use or display of a deadly weapon. The charged subsection and the evidence control the classification.
What if the other person says they were not actually afraid?
That statement can be important evidence, but it does not automatically end the case. Prosecutors may point to 911 calls, body-camera footage, witnesses, and the person’s behavior during the encounter. The defense should compare every statement and preserve evidence that undermines the claimed fear.
Do angry words alone prove assault?
Not automatically. Words are part of the context, but the statute requires conduct that intentionally or knowingly causes reasonable fear of imminent bodily injury. The surrounding circumstances—gestures, distance, movement, and the ability to carry out a threat—matter to the analysis.
Can a fear-based assault charge be dismissed?
Potentially. Cases may be dismissed or reduced when the evidence cannot establish reasonable fear, imminence, or the required mental state, or when self-defense or credibility problems undermine the prosecution. Outcomes depend on the facts and the law; no result is guaranteed.
What should I do after being charged?
Follow all bond conditions, do not contact the alleged victim if a no-contact condition exists, preserve any video, messages, and witness information, and speak with a defense attorney before discussing the incident with investigators.
Free Consultation and Payment Plans Available
For a confidential review of a fear-of-bodily-injury assault charge in Nashville or Middle Tennessee, call 615-205-7311 or text Kevin Kennedy Law Firm. Consultation is free, and payment plans are available. Case outcomes depend on the facts, evidence, and applicable law.
Related Nashville Criminal Defense Pages
Legal references: Tenn. Code Ann. §§ 39-13-101, 39-11-611, 39-11-612, and 40-35-111. This page provides general legal information, not legal advice. The law applicable to the offense date and the specific charged subsection should be reviewed with an attorney.